No. |
Item |
24. |
Declarations of Interest
Members will be asked to make any declarations
of interest in respect of items on this agenda.
Additional documents:
Minutes:
In accordance with the code of conduct the
following declarations of interest were made –
Member
|
Subject
|
Reason
|
Interest
|
Councillor Johnson
|
Minute
|
Governor at Compton School and a Trustee at Operation
Encompass
|
Personal
|
Councillor R Smith
|
Minute
|
Governor at All Saints Academy
|
Personal
|
Councillor Winter
|
Minute
|
Governor at Marine Academy Plymouth
|
Personal
|
Nicky
Williams
|
Minute
|
Board
Member of Plymouth Teaching School Alliance
|
Personal
|
|
25. |
Minutes PDF 82 KB
To confirm the minutes of the previous meeting
held on 19 September 2018.
Additional documents:
Minutes:
Agreed the minutes of the
meeting of 19 September 2018 with an amendment to the attendance
list to include that Councillor Goslin was present at the
meeting.
|
26. |
Chair's Urgent Business
To receive reports on business, which in the opinion of the Chair, should be brought
forward for urgent consideration.
Additional documents:
Minutes:
There were no items of Chair’s Urgent
Business.
|
27. |
Ofsted Update - verbal
Additional documents:
Minutes:
Councillor McDonald (Cabinet Member for
Children and Young People) and Neelam Bhardwaja (Service Director
for Children and Families) were present for this item. It was highlighted that –
(a)
|
|
the inspection had highlighted the strengthens
and improvements to be made;
|
(b)
|
|
strengths include -
·
progress made since last inspection in 2014;
·
assessment undertaken had improved;
·
engagement with children and young people;
·
timeliness of assessments.
|
(c)
|
|
areas for improvement include –
·
the recording of supervision;
·
smarter plans to include timescales and accountability for
tasks.
|
(d)
|
|
they looked at each service area with a focus
on caseloads;
|
(e)
|
|
the virtual school and SEND was also part of
the inspection. Ofsted were assured
that investment was appropriate and driving forward improved
outcomes for children. They also look
at the assurance and compliance around our most vulnerable children
in education.
|
In response to questions raised, it was
reported that –
(f)
|
|
following the phone call from Ofsted on Friday
they expect to receive the draft full report within the next 10
days and then have 3 days to check for factual
accuracies. Once this has taken place
the full report would be published on their website;
|
(g)
|
|
there were 284 children currently being home
educated, this number fluctuates week by week and has tripled in
recent years in line with national trend. They regularly check the quality of education and
work closely with parents to ensure that it is appropriate for the
child;
|
(h)
|
|
if a child had been excluded from school and
meets the category for the local authority to place then they
won’t be elective home schooled during that period because we
would be looking to place the child, where you might find home
educated when waiting choice for a managed transfer rather than an
exclusion;
|
(i)
|
|
if the looked after child was subject to a
care order then the local authority has the parental responsibility
and we would never opt for home education.
|
The Committee noted the verbal update and
requested the Ofsted Report to be provided at a future meeting.
|
28. |
Children's Services Business Plans and Budgets PDF 99 KB
Additional documents:
Minutes:
Councillor Jon Taylor (Cabinet Member for
Education, Skills and Transformation), Councillor McDonald (Cabinet
Member for Children and Young People), Judith Harwood (Service
Director for Education, Participation and Skills), Neelam Bhardwaja
(Service Director for Children, Young People and Families) and
David Bowles (Head of Education) were present for this item and
referred to the report in the agenda.
In response to questions raised, it was
reported that –
(a)
|
|
the SEND Strategy covers the needs of the
child and significant work within the new framework undertaken with
parents gave an oversight of the presentations within different
social situations and family life. They
do not go into detail within the business plan but do go into more
detail within the SEND Strategic Plan;
|
(b)
|
|
this business plan sets out how we would work
with schools that have the accountability and the responsibility on
how they respond to Ofsted. We do
however work very closely with the schools but the business plan
does not reflect the changes to Ofsted framework;
|
(c)
|
|
the Pledges do not exactly match the
priorities for the department, but would be the best place for that
Pledge to sit. The Carers Pledge
ensuring the right learning environment, support for children
within the school help them take control and to become confident
learners;
|
(d)
|
|
the legislation sets out that local
authorities have the duty to be the champion of all
children’s outcomes irrespective of the schools they
attend;
|
(e)
|
|
through Careers SW they have the STEM
Ambassador Programme, they also receive funding from the Local
Enterprise Partnership (LEP) and higher education for the next
STEPS Programme and 15 of the secondary schools were involved with
the LEP. They were making sure that the
offer would be there for all young people;
|
|
|
|
(f)
|
|
the extent that early years was represented
within the business plan was through
attainment outcomes within early years foundation
stage. In the Plan for Education there
was a reference for place shaping, capacity etc but not detailed
within the business plan. As part of
the next refresh would look at the 30 hours provision. Children Centres would sit within commissioning
strategies;
|
(g)
|
|
they had not attempted to list all of the
statutory functions within the business plan but focused on the
priorities. SACRE if included would sit
under attainment and raising aspirations;
|
(h)
|
|
the supported placement includes 4 to 5 very
young people that they could not find placements for given their
complexities of their behaviour. This
resulted in the local authority having to create placements for
them which involved finding accommodation and around the clock
staff for about 6 to 7 weeks at a cost of £980k. One placement was jointly funded with the CCG
costing the local authority £50k a week. This child was
subject to a court protection order and no changes can be made
without the agreement of the official solicitor and the court;
|
(i)
|
|
a recently published report on the mental
health needs of young people highlighted that 25% of young people
under ...
view the full minutes text for item 28.
|
|
29. |
Children, Young People and Families Social Worker recruitment and Social Workers' case loads PDF 30 KB
Additional documents:
Minutes:
Councillor McDonald (Cabinet Member for
Children and Young People) and Neelam Bhardwaja (Service Director
for Children, Young People and Families) were present for this item
and referred to the report within the agenda.
In response to questions
raised, it was reported that -
(a)
|
|
that the team manager would have an
awareness of experience, expertise and resilience of each of the
social workers within their team.
However, they do have staff on long term sick but sickness levels
within the service area was well below the target and had been for
a sustained period of time. This was
reflected by Ofsted who reported that staff morale was high, people
felt supported and managers were
supportive and visible;
|
(b)
|
|
workload meeting takes place weekly
and once month they review time taken
off in lieu and extra hours of work.
Some teams were working their contracted hours but those teams
involved in court proceedings could work up to an extra 10
hours. This should not become the norm
or expectation and encourage staff to take the time off for
recovery and for manager to have oversight of this;
|
(c)
|
|
the social worker as reported in
the local press was an agency worker.
The referral and assessment
service was not functioning properly which resulted in a
reorganisation of the service. They now
have a robust system in place to deal with performance
issues. There should be records in
place on the action taken at that time;
|
(d)
|
|
they were working more
proactively with each of the teams so that social workers could
undertake the work that needs to be done and that other elements of
the role could be undertaken by someone else with the
team;
|
(e)
|
|
they commission ACE to undertake
the active home visit and if concerns comeback around safeguarding
they would send an Inclusion and Welfare Officer to visit the
home. There was a provision within the
law to work with either social care or the police if a child was at
risk of harm but was pleased to report that there were no
cases;
|
(f)
|
|
social workers often express
which area they wish to specialise in but also request to work
within another service area to broaden their experience and
expertise;
|
(g)
|
|
they look at the child’s
journey through the system and management looks at the service area
as a whole to manage the pressures across the service
area.
|
The Committee noted the report.
|
30. |
Plymouth Education Board PDF 173 KB
Additional documents:
Minutes:
Councillor Jon Taylor (Cabinet Member
for Education, Skills and Transformation), Judith Harwood (Service
Director for Education, Participation and Skills) and David Bowles
(Head of Education) were present for this item and referred to the
report included in the agenda.
In response to questions raised, it
was reported that –
(a)
|
|
Higher Education (HE) had been included on the
Board because they are our education partners that work with
particular schools. This Board
represents all sectors and phases of education and HE bring a
different perspective to the discussion;
|
(b)
|
|
Ivybridge Community College is a school of
choice for parents within the city because of the good Ofsted
rating and specialities in sport.
Ivybridge is also part of the
WeST MAT which includes primary and
secondary schools from Plymouth;
|
(b)
|
|
the Board was set
up in September 2017 and throughout the summer term 2017 a working
group was set up to establish the Board. 10 years ago and beyond the system was not
fragmented because schools were maintained and there were very few
academies and schools worked very closely together;
|
(c)
|
|
that a solution
nationally was to bring in more MATs but there was a reluctance for
MATs to come to the city as well as stand-alone academies entering
into a MAT. There were definitely
things we could do locally and have a role in developing MATs;
|
(d)
|
|
the Board would have the more strategic
conversations and delegates work to the different groups attached
to the Board;
|
(e)
|
|
the oracy project
was funded by various sources throughout the city and an update on
the oracy project can be provided to
the Committee;
|
(f)
|
|
Torbridge Primary
School has been issued with an Academy order following their recent
Ofsted report. Action has been taken
action to strengthen governance and to improve various aspects of
the school. A recovery programme would
be completed by the end of this week and were working closely with
the Regional School Commissioner;
|
(g)
|
|
they operate a
system where people can opt out but it’s about making sure
they want to be part of the conversation. All the sectors are represented on the Board and
one of the biggest challenges for head teachers is the rotation of
their representatives and ensuring that they work on the
communications to keep the momentum.
|
Agreed that the Committee
receive an update on the Oracy
Project.
|
31. |
Work Programme PDF 133 KB
Additional documents:
Minutes:
The Committee discussed items for
inclusion on the work programme. The
Chair highlighted a particular issue around the carrying of weapons
and drugs in school. Following a short
debate, Members felt that some of the issues raised were outside
the remit of this Committee.
The Committee therefore agreed
–
1. To add
to the work programme bullying including how the Personal, Social,
Health and Economic Education (PSHE) is delivered across the
city.
2. That a
briefing paper is provided on number of incidents of weapons and
drugs being brought into schools during the last year.
|
32. |
Tracking Resolutions PDF 31 KB
Additional documents:
Minutes:
The Committee noted the tracking
resolutions.
|