Agenda and minutes

Venue: Warspite Room, Council House

Contact: Jake Metcalfe  Email: democraticsupport@plymouth.gov.uk

Items
No. Item

13.

Declarations of Interest

Councillors will be asked to make any declarations of interest in respect to items on the agenda.

Minutes:

There were no declarations of interest.

14.

Minutes pdf icon PDF 138 KB

To confirm the minutes of the previous meeting held on 18 July 2023.

Minutes:

The minutes of the meeting held on 18 July were agreed as a true and accurate record.

15.

Chair's Urgent Business

To receive reports on business which in the opinion of the Chair, should be brought forward for urgent consideration.

Minutes:

Councillor Creswell provided an update and advised that the Council had been proactive in communicating with school leaders as parents and carers were concerned about the use of reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RAAC) in school buildings. Since 2018, surveys were carried out on the 14 local authority maintained schools and none had been found to contain RAAC. The Education team contacted Chief Executives of Academy’s and Head Teachers to confirm that relative checks had taken place.

16.

Work Programme pdf icon PDF 124 KB

Minutes:

The Committee agreed to note the work programme.

17.

Tracking Decisions pdf icon PDF 182 KB

Minutes:

Paul Stephens (Performance Advisor) explained an answer to a question on the response regarding the stepping up from Child in Need plan to Child Protection and stepping back down from Child in Need to Universal that due to lack of resourcing prioritisation had been carried out and that explained why the work had not been developed. It had been placed on a list for future development.

David Haley (Interim Service Director for Children’s Services and DCS) responded to a question regarding timeframe for that piece of work that an agreement had been put in place to share resource with adult social care to draw the data out for the agreed work.

The Committee agreed to note the work programme.

 

18.

Local Area SEND inspection: report and briefing pdf icon PDF 154 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Councillor Cresswell (Cabinet Member for Education, Skills and Apprenticeships) and Annie Gammon (Service Director for Education, Participation and Skills) presented the report to the Committee and highlighted the following key points:

 

a)     

The Council regretted the report and accepted Ofsted’s findings and would work with the Local Area Partnership to improve services for the city’s most vulnerable and would look to build in a bright future for all its SEN users;

 

b)     

The Council would be making arrangements to hold an improvement Board meeting in September which would continue 6 weekly thereafter in order to make sustained change at pace with the help of Ofsted and partners;

 

c)     

Ofsted recognised that there were some areas of strength within the partnership which included commitment, some strong working schools, some strong work with Plymouth’s youngest children, some work with post 16 children and some work with social and emotional needs;

 

d)     

Areas of improvement included making children with SEND the centre of improvement plans, with clear oversight and tracking to measure impact. Plymouth should be better at understanding increased risk to children with SEND;

 

e)     

Plymouth should reduce the risk of a child/young person being excluded where they had an EHCP;

 

f)      

Plymouth required to be consistent with all children around the healthy child programme;

 

g)     

The Parent Carer Forum had been actively involved and helped the Local Area Partnership with the plan and help determine what the outcomes would be for children with SEND;

 

In response to questions raised it was reported that:

 

h)     

There would be changes to professional development for staff to enact change in culture across the partnership to put children with SEND at the heart of everything the service did;

 

i)      

There were increases in the number of young children coming up to school age, following Covid with limited language and was an area of focus through the stronger practice hub. There was a rolling program of training with a special educational needs co-coordinator and this would need to be pulled together as part of the SEND improvement planning;

 

j)      

Part time timetables should only be used as a temporary measure and all children should be in full time education. They were too prevalent in Plymouth that was used to regularly by schools and work was on-going with schools in Plymouth to remedy;

 

k)     

Most children with an EHCP in Plymouth were in mainstream education however it was acknowledged the Plymouth had a shortage of places requiring the correct provision and a sufficiency plan was underway to create more spaces. The Council was exploring a number of options which included opening a further provision and increasing existing provisions;

 

l)      

To ensure all schools in the city were working to good outcomes for Plymouth SEND children, the partnership would need to create a common goal. The council offered support and had undertaken an audit of its secondary schools to make them aware of what could be done and what training was in place. There were assurances from Department  ...  view the full minutes text for item 18.

19.

Unlocking Plymouth's Potential 2023 to 2025 pdf icon PDF 181 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Councillor Cresswell (Cabinet Member for Education, Skills and Apprenticeships), Tina Brinkworth (Head of Skills and Post 16) and Annie Gammon (Service Director for Education, Participation and Skills) presented the report to the Committee and highlighted the following key points:

 

a)     

The plan allowed a way in which the council could work across the system but in a preventative model to introduce early interventions and prevent people becoming not in education, employment and training;

 

b)     

Young people in the SEND cohort would transition to education and training at a rate of 1 in 2 and very few transitioned into employment;

 

c)     

A care experienced young person transitioned into education, training and employment at a rate of 1 in 5 and this was the same for those in the criminal justice system;

 

d)     

Early employment pathways in the city existed in very low numbers and a SEND employment forum was established, the Council had grown its supported internship numbers from nine to 49, was working hard to grow supported apprenticeship opportunities and other innovative pathways that would lead to employment.

 

In response to questions raised it was reported that:

 

e)     

There were many people and organisations operating across the city, but were operating in silo’s. The council would not need to provide additional funding as it was already present but partners and the council were not working effectively across the system and the Unlocking Plymouth’s Potential strategy would bring it all together and drive it across Plymouth in a coordinated approach. The strategy would triage young people more appropriately;

 

The Committee agreed to note the report.

 

 

20.

Educational perspectives on Emotional Health and Wellbeing (EHWB) pdf icon PDF 286 KB

Minutes:

Councillor Cresswell (Cabinet Member for Education, Skills and Apprenticeships), Clare Hetherington (Principal Educational Psychologist) and Rachel Crozier (ACE) presented the report to the Committee and highlighted the following key points:

 

a)     

Good mental health was important for children and young people to develop and thrive. Emotional health and wellbeing influenced their cognitive development and ability to engage with learning. It also affected physical and social health;

 

b)     

Ofsted’s school inspection handbook set out what inspectors took account of to ensure schools provided high quality pastoral care to enable pupils and students to develop into resilient adults with good mental health. All schools had a statutory duty to promote the welfare of their pupils and students, including preventing impairment of health or development as set out in Keeping Children Safe in Education (updated 2023) statutory guidance;

 

c)     

The Special Educational Needs and Disability (SEND) Code of Practice defined Social Emotional Mental Health (SEMH) difficulties whereby children may experience a wide range of needs that manifest themselves in many ways. These included becoming withdrawn or isolated, as well as displaying challenging, disruptive or disturbing behaviour. These behaviours may have reflected underlying mental health difficulties such as anxiety or depression, self-harming, substance misuse, eating disorders or physical symptoms that are medically unexplained. Other children and young people may have had needs related to attention deficit, hyperactivity, or attachment (and/or trauma). The experiences and needs of children and young people should always be understood in the context of environmental factors within the home, community and school/setting. Children experiencing primary SEMH SEND need may have been impacted by other needs such as in the areas of communication and interaction and/or cognition and learning;

 

d)     

The Children and Families Act (2014) placed a duty on local authorities to ensure integration of education, health and social care to promote wellbeing and improve quality of provision for disabled young people and those with SEND;

 

e)     

The following plans supported EHWB in Plymouth for all pupils, as well as those with additional needs, are highlighted for reference:

 

· A Bright Future 2021-2026

· NHS Long Term Plan – focus on emotional mental health

· SEND Strategy

· Area SEND Inspection Priority Action Plan (in development)

· Inclusion Strategy task and finish group facilitated by the place-based plan

· Special Educational Needs graduated approach to Inclusion and iThrive frameworks.

 

f)      

The Emotional Health and Wellbeing Steering Group met quarterly and was chaired by a Plymouth city council Public Health Officer. Representatives attended from Education, Health and Independent Sector providers. The group provided a forum to support optimisation of the system through local organisations and agencies coming together. Updates and information sharing provided opportunity for partnership, collaboration and improved system effectiveness. The work supported the system to share and co-own the vision and ambition of a Bright Future;

 

g)     

The Trauma Informed Plymouth Network was an independent network where the ambition for Plymouth was to be a trauma informed city. It had an education branch providing a reflective learning space for mainstream, specialist and higher education staff  ...  view the full minutes text for item 20.

21.

Domestic Abuse and Children as Survivors pdf icon PDF 152 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Councillor Hayden (Cabinet Member for Community Safety, Libraries, Cemeteries and Crematoria) introduced the item to the Committee and made the following points:

a) Plymouth OFSTED report in December 2022 highlighted areas of improvement required around Plymouth’s Domestic Abuse Practice, including improved triaging of domestic abuse cases, improved use of domestic abuse risk assessment tools and improved partnership working with Plymouth’s local specialists;

b) Plymouth made significant efforts to improve the city wide response including coordinating a community response accreditation in July 23 and began working with Standing Together Against Domestic Abuse to be the first area in the UK to pilot the whole system approach, this would include reinstating the multi-agency assessment conference steering approach to address high risk domestic abuse in the city;

c) Launch of Plymouth’s Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG) strategy in 2023-2035 action plan and city wide training programme for the VAWG;

d) Domestic Abuse policy was refreshed and the Council had white ribbon accreditation;

e) Held first M.A.N Culture conference in September 23.

Matt Garrett (Service Director for Community Connections) added:

f) Re-procurement of the Domestic Abuse service was set to include an expanded offer for children with the understanding that children were victims of DA in their own right;

g) Training provided for internal social workers around PSCP Safeguarding and DA as well as Risk Assessment training and additional training from technical lead around DA and what it meant;

h) Specialist Services for children from Barnardos had been changed to help victims and survivors make more sense of the relationships they were in;

i) Planned work included: workforce development to increase social worker confidence, strengthen the Whole Family Approach, shadowing opportunities with Plymouth Domestic Abuse service, continuing to improve information sharing, implemented the Whole School’s Approach in Autumn 2023 and co-ordinated Community Response Accreditation and MARAC review;

j) Safer Together Model would support Plymouth in responding to Ofsted concerns by working in a holistic way to protect children and keep them in the home and working around increasing the amount of support to people who harm to prevent them harming in the future.

In response to the questions raised it was reported that:

k) The work in the city wasn’t doing what it should and the procurement of the new contract and the conversations happening at Plymouth’s Domestic Abuse Sexual Violence sub group from Safer Plymouth is all about increasing the amount of support to children, how children were viewed as part of being victims of DA and looking at specialist therapeutic support to try and improve the offer to young people across the city;

l) Held an event with providers in the city for the contract for Domestic Abuse Service;

m) The join up with Community Safety impacted positively in relation to Children’s Services working within Multi-Agency Safeguarding Hub (MASH), the two things that helped were staff undertaking training with the tools and embedded this within the service and worked with other staff to model the approach to triage; and the second  ...  view the full minutes text for item 21.

22.

Children’s Services Finance Report pdf icon PDF 155 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The report was taken as read and the Committee moved to questions where it was reported that:

 

The service had some capacity to deliver independent travel training for children/young people that were using school transport delivered by the Council. This was part of the plans to reduce spend in the budget but would also create a great opportunity for children/young people in the city to gain some independence;

 

The Committee agreed to note the report.

23.

Q1 2023/24 Performance Report

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The report was taken as read and the Committee agreed to note the report.

24.

Plymouth Children’s Services Improvement Plan pdf icon PDF 158 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Councillor Laing (Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Children’s Social Care, Culture, Events and Communications) and David Haley (Director for Children’s Services) presented the report to the Committee and highlighted the following key points:

 

a)     

The Council had initiated a recruitment and retention plan and would see staff in area’s of the children social work service receive retention payments to ensure a stable workforce that would help drive improvement work. The Council would also cover the cost of social work registrations;

 

b)     

Dorset County Council, Plymouth’s sector led improvement partner had undertaken a deep dive of the Multi-agency Safeguarding Hub (MASH) which highlighted urgent work required to ensure no drift or delay for children was occurring at the service’s front door. The service had worked hard to remedy the actions required and all children were having an outcome within the 24 hour timescale;

 

c)     

There was additional management capacity in place and work was underway to improve the partner threshold guidance;

 

d)     

Some areas of the service were experiencing high workloads which was a knock on effect from what was discovered in the MASH;

 

e)     

There would be increased capacity within the Initial Response Teams and Children’s Social Work service as the bulge in work moved through the department;

 

f)      

The consultation for the Targeted Operating Model (TOM) had ended and a phased plan for introduction of locality model would be implemented;

 

g)     

The Improvement Plan was being refreshed and would have a clearer focus for the service over the next 3-6 months and progress would be available at the next scrutiny meeting.

 

In response to questions raised it was reported that:

 

a)     

The service was committed and determined to bring about changes that were required. Engagement and ownership had been key in the first few weeks to bring about change for the service. The Social Work Academy was exploring models to help social workers with their emotional health and wellbeing into the future;

 

b)     

The service would be increasing capacity in areas of the service to reduce pressures on workloads for the staff and the international recruitment of social workers had been going well;

 

c)     

Health checks for cared for children were improving and it was noted that the health team nurses were well embedded in the service. Dentistry was an issue not just for Plymouth but nationally, but work was on-going in the city to address the issues.

 

The Committee agreed to note the report.

 

 

 

 

25.

Unregistered Arrangements Update

Minutes:

Councillor Laing (Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Children’s Social Care, Culture, Events and Communications) and David Haley (Interim Director of Children’s Services) presented the report to the Committee and highlighted the following key points:

 

There was a shortage of placements for children/young people across the country and the market was competitive and expensive;

 

a)     

Members of the committee were urged to read the report from the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) which stated that 83% of residential placements in the country were delivered by the private market. It was noted that Plymouth City Council did not have any of its own residential provision in the city;

 

b)     

There more children in independent fostering provision rather than in house fostering provision and it was a priority to grow the provision;

 

c)     

There needed to be a national conversation around what was required to effect change within the market;

 

d)     

There were five children in unregulated placements for the Council which was a reduction from seven in August 2023. This area was a priority action for the Council and the target was to have no children in unregulated provision;

 

e)     

Two children/young people were awaiting met the requirements for a secure placement but there were 40 children nationally awaiting this type of placement;

 

f)      

From the end of the financial year, all post 16 provision would be required to be regulated and work was on-going from the Commissioning team to understand how Plymouth’s providers were going to manage the transition;

 

g)     

Plymouth was producing a quality list of providers that could deliver unregulated arrangements should they be required;

 

h)     

Plymouth worked well with its providers in the city and one of them would be opening a two bed crisis home which would alleviate issues of unregulated provisions.

 

In response to questions raised it was reported that:

 

i)      

Foster carers were in the older cohort and nationally work was required to remedy a more broad fostering culture.